So here I wrote up an idea I had that was prompted by my love for food reviews and writing them. I wanted something comprehensive, like a bible or encyclopedia of personal reviews and experiences dining certain places. I post below both my idea, and then the response I received to it from a thoughtful, Internet-savvy friend.
Idea:
I’ve been trying to synthesize this idea I’ve had about aggregating data or opinions rather from review cites. What I was wanting was a website that would assimilate data from different information sources. For instance if you wanted to look up how to use a staple gun, it would take the information from ehow.com and about.com and a website on home improvement and would some how (perhaps through user reviews or editing like in wiki) update the information to reflect the most comprehensive and accurate info. This idea sounds a lot like wikihow; however, I was wanting to expand it to user forums of businesses (to like yelp, tripadvisor and urbanspoon) to synthesize data reviewing local businesses that way you’d not have to look up hotels or restaurants on google, yelp, and trip advisor to find the best “x” within a locale, but would have one source at your fingertips to use. What I realized in conceiving this idea was that I basically wanted a user-reviewer based encyclopedia like Wikipedia to cover everything on the web definitively. Probably on its way in the form of a wiki-something…
Response:
I’ve had the same thoughts, but review sites come and go too frequently to have a one-stop shop that could keep up with it all. ProductWiki is kind of nice because you can create your own entries and populate external reviews – but it’s not for places, only things. I’ve been meaning to add another entry for the Paul Mitchell Tea Tree Hair and Body Moisturizer that I love.
Just stick with Google, Yelp, TripAdvisor separate searches.